Pick your lineup

[NYgiantsfan5689]

I think Nady can provide better protection than Matsui or Posada at this point. Both are huge question marks. Nady has more speed, hits well with RISP and is used to hitting fifth.

They're more question marks in the field or with their health than they are with the bat. They're both solid with the bat

[ljshorty89]

Well, Matsui has shown to be a solid hitter (when healthy), but with Posada, you never know with catchers as they get another year older. He's probably closer to .270, 17, 75 or so, then he is to his last full season of an insane .338, 20, 90.

[love_that_reefer]

They're more question marks in the field or with their health than they are with the bat. They're both solid with the bat

Hard to hit when your legs and shoulder hurt. Hard to get out of the box when your legs hurt. Hard to play baseball when your legs and shoulder hurt. Like I said, I this point, Nady is the best option.

[browntown653]

1. Teixeira
2. Rodriguez
3. Matsui
4. Nady
5. Damon
6. Cano
7. Swisher
8. Jeter
9. Posada

Best lineup according to Baseball Musings...no, seriously

[ljshorty89]

Umm....something tells me that won't be how Girardi's opening day lineup card looks.