Colorado trades:
RF Matt Holliday, 4.0 stars, $6,800,000
SP Brad Penny, 1.5 stars, $3,120,000
Total: $9,920,000
Philadelphia trades:
1B Tim Taylor, 5.0 spec, MLC
2B Gaston Marquardt, 5.0 spec, MLC
3B Armando Ortiz, 4.0 spec, MLC
1B Victor Diaz, 2.0 stars, $4,350,000 (salary dump)
Total: $4,350,000
I used a calculator, the deal barely does work with Philly's financial situation