Padres VS Giants 2007 You Decide

[trevortime101]

Catcher:

Giants
Ryan Doumit (3.5p) 6-7-7-5-4

Padres
Jeff Mathis (4.0p) 6-6-6-6-6

First Base:

Giants
Xavier Nady (2.5) 7-7-7-7-6

Padres
Adrian Gonzales (5.0p) 8-7-7-6-6

Second Base

Giants
Alfonso Soriano (3.0) 7-9-9-5-5

Padres
Howie Kendrick (4.0p) 8-8-6-4-8

Third Base

Giants
Lance Nikero (2.5) 7-8-7-4-6

Padres
Garret Atkins (2.0) 7-8-6-9-7

Short Stop

Giants
Nomar! (2.5) 9-9-7-4-8

Padres
Kahlil Greene (2.5) 6-8-8-5-5

Left Field

Giants
Jason Bay (4.5) 7-9-9-10-4

Padres
Carlos Lee (3.5) 7-9-10-6-7

Center Field

Giants
Randy Winn (2.5) 7-9-6-5-6

Padres
Mike Cameron (4.0p) 5-7-8-8-4

Right Field

Giants
Jeff Francouer (5.0) 8-9-9-5-4

Padres
Frank Cantilona (2.0) 7-8-5-4-7

Giants Rotation
SP: Tim Hudson (4.0) 7-9-10
SP: Matt Morris (3.5) 7-9-8
SP: Jose Contreras (2.5) 9-6-8
SP: Noah Lowery (2.5) 9-7-7
SP: Paul Maholm (4.0p) 5-8-8


Padres Rotation
SP: Jered Weaver (5.0p) 9-8-7
SP: Barry Zito (3.5) 8-7-9
SP: John Lackey (2.5) 9-7-7
SP: Cesar Carillo (5.0p) 8-7-8
SP: Chris Young (2.5) 7-8-8

Giants Bullpen
SP/LR: Jake Westbrook (2.5) 5-9-8
LR(L): Alan Embree (1.5) 8-7-8
MR(R): Brian Wilson (4.0p) 8-5-7
MR(L): Jack Taschtner (1.5) 7-6-7
MOP: Merkin Valdez (3.0p) 7-5-7
SET: Mike Gonzales (4.0) 9-5-9
CL: A. Benitez (4.0) 9-10-8

Padres Bullpen
Clay Hensley (2.0) 6-8-7
Mike Wuertz (1.5) 8-6-6
Willy Eyre (3.0) 6-7-8
Felix Rodriguez (2.5) 8-7-7
Scott Cassidy (2.5) 8-6-6
Julio Mateo (4.0) 7-8-9
Scott Linebrink (4.0) 9-8-9

Giants Bench:
C: Mike Mathany (1.0) 4-6-3-4-5 10 Def and Arm
UTIL: Jerry Hariston (2.0) 6-7-4-6-7
UTIL: Alex Cintron (2.5) 6-8-5-3-8
OF: Carl Everett (1.0) 6-7-7-4-5
OF: Jason Ellison (1.0) 6-7-4-4-7

Padres Bench
Dave Roberts (1.5) 7-6-4-6-8
Josh Bard (1.0) 6-5-3-5-7
Josh Barfield (3.5p) 7-8-6-6-5
Mark Bellhorn (2.0) 5-6-7-10-3


too muh typing.... rock the vote

[Dry1313]

Your team is the oldest in the league too...

While mine is the 7th youngest. When your players start to slowly die while mine progress, epecially in the pitching areas, you'll be done.

[General]

I'll take the Pads' offense but Giants pitching. However, my experience with older pitching has been that it dies.

[nick]

other: lloyd mcclendon

[DravenX]

The Giants because well I said so.

[bjd2933]

I like the Pads... maybe not even for this season, but definately for the long haul, San Diego is set for the future.

[DiamondDave]

Personally... I am not impressed with SD at all, for a team claiming to be a W.S. contender

[Halladay_is_God]

I like neither team as a contender but the Giants impress me more as a whole