Who out there has had worse luck with first round picks?
I took over for Waruv/Fishercat before the 2019 Draft.
2019: Abram Fisher - serviceable #3-#4 in the roto SP
2020: Robert Plant - crashed and burned. never made the bigs.
2021: Theodore Butera - crashed control and movement. horrible career ERA
2022: Mark Robinson - lost movement and has been mediocre ever since
2023: Sixto DeStefano - crashed control and movement... traded... Zito rehabbed, 1 good year this year, average last year.
2024: Calvin Manno - lost movement and possibly control... I think he was 10-8-8. Nick could rehab still, but 5.71 career ERA so far through 2 seasons.
2025: Eloy Palos - crashed stuff and movement... worthless now
2026: Jon Vides - drafted at 10-7-8... crashed movement... looks like a bust.
2026: Franklin Schulller - was a 5.0 but crashed for Florida and is likely worthless
2027: Adan Young - auto picked...was a 4.5 IIRC and crashed and is now worthless
2028: Lonnie Mooney - 5 endurance SP... so far so good
2029: Matthew Pendergrast - was 7-9-8, just shit to bed and is now a 7-8-6...
After 10 years... Not one single All star and the only decent MLB guy, I traded.