Nominations for the best 16 players in M's History.

[Porter]

Jeffery Leonard had some good years but i didnt consider him for that list.

Vizquel is very intriguing, as is Henderson for they did have good seasons. Vizquel more for defense.

[Fishercat]

Here is Rob Neyer's #1 All-Time Mariners team (note: From 2002, so current breakout players like Ichiro will not be on here).

DH: Edgar Martinez
C: Dan Wilson
1B: Alan Davis
2B: Harold Reynolds
SS: Alex Rodriguez
3B: Edgar Martinez (again)
LF: Phil Bradley
CF: Ken Griffey Jr.
RF: Jay Buhner (I'd consider him...)
SP: RJ, Moyer, Langston, Garcia
RP: Sasaki

Among your nominees and excluding newer players, the only guy on the #2 team is Jim Presley. Your choices seem pretty good. Presley and Wilson were similar players and Wilson was there longer. Likely, either one of them is just playing to be the play-in seed to the #1 crushing, but whatever.

[redsrbetter]

I like the 16 you have right now Porter

[Porter]

Dan Wilson is good catcher and has been for a sustained period of time. And looking over both players carrer Numbers. It could be down to these 3 players for the last spot

Vizquel
Wilson
Presley

Those are the 3 that either can A) cause a playin game (17th player) or B) cause a debate for the 16th spot. who will lose to the #1.

[Providence A's]

Mike Moore!

5th career wins
3rd career innings
2nd most innings in a season
4th career strikeouts
3rd career games started
1st career complete games
2nd career shutouts
1st career losses

[Porter]

Mike Morrs Career ERA isnt in the top 10, he has a .407 Career Win %.

Higher WHIP than Langston (1.37)
Higher Hits/9 than Holman (9.04)
Walked more than 3 per inning.
Has a lower Adj ERA+ than Ryan Franklin, Chris Bosio.......

Wont be considered for the top 16.

[Slyder]

Ive got one name you left off for laughs :-D





keep on scrolling














keep on scrolling








Dave Kingman

[Providence A's]

Walked more than 3 per inning.

So he walked in a run almost every inning?

[Porter]

per 9 innings.