Originally Posted by
Fishercat
Soriano is only an upgrade on Loretta if Loretta cannot return to 03-04 levels. Soriano was better in 2003, but a LOT of Soriano's value is in slugging.
Let me give you two lines (BA-OBP-SLG)
0.268 0.309 0.512
0.271 0.315 0.412
Both are AL second basemen and the stats are '05. The bottom one is one of the best defensive MI in baseball as well. The only difference between the two is their slugging. The top? Soriano. The bottom? Orlando Hudson.
Soriano's power has to take a hit coming to San Diego, and considering Loretta's potential to perform (as in 03 and 04), why risk it unless you're really high on Nix?