QB elimination game (read the rules)

[Mr. D™]

I guess its okay to hate the Steelers and Big Ben, we did after all win the super bowl. Although your opinion was based on a biased because your a "Who Dey" fan rather than eliminating which QB's are worse. Which in turn would make the game that much better, oh as well as a bit more realistic.

PS +Brett Favre
-Carson Palmer

Ben isn't anywhere near as good as Palmer tho

it wasn't ben that had the major factor for the steelers to win the super bowl tho

and it's a rivalry reaction for me, if you havn't noticed I have been going against every QB from the AFCN already eliminated the steelers and Raven's QB now i'm going after the browns

all it is to Baseballfanatic is that there are alot of red fans here and he believes palmer will win cause of that lol

[Mr. D™]

+ Palmer
- Frye

Carson Palmer (17)
Philip Rivers (13)
Tom Brady (11)
Jake Delhomme (11)
Aaron Brooks (10)
Mark Brunell (10)
Marc Bulger (10)
David Carr (10)
Daunte Culpepper (10)
Trent Green (10)
Rex Grossman (10)
Matt Hasselbeck (10)
Brad Johnson (10)
Jon Kitna (10)
Byron Leftwich (10)
JP Losman (10)
Donovan McNabb (10)
Jake Plummer (10)
Chris Simms (10)
Alex Smith (10)
Billy Volek (10)
Chad Pennington (10)
Kurt Warner (8)
Michael Vick (8)
Eli Manning (8)
Drew Brees (8)
Brett Favre (7)
Charlie Frye (6)
Peyton Manning (6)

Eliminated - Please do not Erase
Ben Roethlisberger
Steve McNair

[Porter]

+ Palmer, Just for last nights performance
- Manning, Peyton

Carson Palmer (18)
Philip Rivers (13)
Tom Brady (11)
Jake Delhomme (11)
Aaron Brooks (10)
Mark Brunell (10)
Marc Bulger (10)
David Carr (10)
Daunte Culpepper (10)
Trent Green (10)
Rex Grossman (10)
Matt Hasselbeck (10)
Brad Johnson (10)
Jon Kitna (10)
Byron Leftwich (10)
JP Losman (10)
Donovan McNabb (10)
Jake Plummer (10)
Chris Simms (10)
Alex Smith (10)
Billy Volek (10)
Chad Pennington (10)
Kurt Warner (8)
Michael Vick (8)
Eli Manning (8)
Drew Brees (8)
Brett Favre (7)
Charlie Frye (6)
Peyton Manning (4)

Eliminated - Please do not Erase
Ben Roethlisberger
Steve McNair

[padrefanforever]

+ Rivers
- Favrerere

Carson Palmer (18)
Philip Rivers (14)
Tom Brady (11)
Jake Delhomme (11)
Aaron Brooks (10)
Mark Brunell (10)
Marc Bulger (10)
David Carr (10)
Daunte Culpepper (10)
Trent Green (10)
Rex Grossman (10)
Matt Hasselbeck (10)
Brad Johnson (10)
Jon Kitna (10)
Byron Leftwich (10)
JP Losman (10)
Donovan McNabb (10)
Jake Plummer (10)
Chris Simms (10)
Alex Smith (10)
Billy Volek (10)
Chad Pennington (10)
Kurt Warner (8)
Michael Vick (8)
Eli Manning (8)
Drew Brees (8)
Charlie Frye (8)
Peyton Manning (6)
Brett Favre (4)

Eliminated - Please do not Erase
Ben Roethlisberger
Steve McNair

[padrefanforever]

ugh.......sorry guys.......this wasn't supposed to post twice...

[Porter]

+ Brady
- Peyton Manning

Carson Palmer (18)
Philip Rivers (14)
Tom Brady (12)
Jake Delhomme (11)
Aaron Brooks (10)
Mark Brunell (10)
Marc Bulger (10)
David Carr (10)
Daunte Culpepper (10)
Trent Green (10)
Rex Grossman (10)
Matt Hasselbeck (10)
Brad Johnson (10)
Jon Kitna (10)
Byron Leftwich (10)
JP Losman (10)
Donovan McNabb (10)
Jake Plummer (10)
Chris Simms (10)
Alex Smith (10)
Billy Volek (10)
Chad Pennington (10)
Kurt Warner (8)
Michael Vick (8)
Eli Manning (8)
Drew Brees (8)
Charlie Frye (8)
Peyton Manning (4)
Brett Favre (4)

[Slyder]

+ Charlie Frye (student of the game)
- Tom Brady (result of the worst replay call in NFL history)

Carson Palmer (18)
Philip Rivers (14)
Tom Brady (11)
Jake Delhomme (11)
Aaron Brooks (10)
Mark Brunell (10)
Marc Bulger (10)
David Carr (10)
Daunte Culpepper (10)
Trent Green (10)
Rex Grossman (10)
Matt Hasselbeck (10)
Brad Johnson (10)
Jon Kitna (10)
Byron Leftwich (10)
JP Losman (10)
Donovan McNabb (10)
Jake Plummer (10)
Chris Simms (10)
Alex Smith (10)
Billy Volek (10)
Chad Pennington (10)
Charlie Frye (9)
Kurt Warner (8)
Michael Vick (8)
Eli Manning (8)
Drew Brees (8)
Peyton Manning (4)
Brett Favre (4)

[Mr. D™]

+ Charlie Frye (student of the game)

see Baseballfanatic looks like i'm going to be going against a fellow Red fan on this one lol

[Slyder]

see Baseballfanatic looks like i'm going to be going against a fellow Red fan on this one lol

He was in a couple of my classes at UA and had his own set of keys to the film room and was almost always working on his craft while not in class.

[Mr. D™]

He was in a couple of my classes at UA and had his own set of keys to the film room and was almost always working on his craft while not in class.

To bad he landed on a bad team

[Mr. D™]

+ Palmer
- Vick

Carson Palmer (19)
Philip Rivers (14)
Tom Brady (11)
Jake Delhomme (11)
Aaron Brooks (10)
Mark Brunell (10)
Marc Bulger (10)
David Carr (10)
Daunte Culpepper (10)
Trent Green (10)
Rex Grossman (10)
Matt Hasselbeck (10)
Brad Johnson (10)
Jon Kitna (10)
Byron Leftwich (10)
JP Losman (10)
Donovan McNabb (10)
Jake Plummer (10)
Chris Simms (10)
Alex Smith (10)
Billy Volek (10)
Chad Pennington (10)
Charlie Frye (9)
Kurt Warner (8)
Eli Manning (8)
Drew Brees (8)
Michael Vick (6)
Peyton Manning (4)
Brett Favre (4)

Eliminated - Please do not Erase
Ben Roethlisberger
Steve McNair

[padrefanforever]

+ Rivers
- Favre

Carson Palmer (19)
Philip Rivers (15)
Tom Brady (11)
Jake Delhomme (11)
Aaron Brooks (10)
Mark Brunell (10)
Marc Bulger (10)
David Carr (10)
Daunte Culpepper (10)
Trent Green (10)
Rex Grossman (10)
Matt Hasselbeck (10)
Brad Johnson (10)
Jon Kitna (10)
Byron Leftwich (10)
JP Losman (10)
Donovan McNabb (10)
Jake Plummer (10)
Chris Simms (10)
Alex Smith (10)
Billy Volek (10)
Chad Pennington (10)
Charlie Frye (9)
Kurt Warner (8)
Eli Manning (8)
Drew Brees (8)
Michael Vick (6)
Peyton Manning (4)
Brett Favre (2)

Eliminated - Please do not Erase
Ben Roethlisberger
Steve McNair

[BaseballFanatic]

+ Rivers
- Palmer

Carson Palmer (17)
Philip Rivers (16)
Tom Brady (11)
Jake Delhomme (11)
Aaron Brooks (10)
Mark Brunell (10)
Marc Bulger (10)
David Carr (10)
Daunte Culpepper (10)
Trent Green (10)
Rex Grossman (10)
Matt Hasselbeck (10)
Brad Johnson (10)
Jon Kitna (10)
Byron Leftwich (10)
JP Losman (10)
Donovan McNabb (10)
Jake Plummer (10)
Chris Simms (10)
Alex Smith (10)
Billy Volek (10)
Chad Pennington (10)
Charlie Frye (9)
Kurt Warner (8)
Eli Manning (8)
Drew Brees (8)
Michael Vick (6)
Peyton Manning (4)
Brett Favre (2)

Eliminated - Please do not Erase
Ben Roethlisberger
Steve McNair

[BaseballFanatic]

+ Pennington
- Palmer

Philip Rivers (16)
Carson Palmer (15)
Chad Pennington (11)
Tom Brady (11)
Jake Delhomme (11)
Aaron Brooks (10)
Mark Brunell (10)
Marc Bulger (10)
David Carr (10)
Daunte Culpepper (10)
Trent Green (10)
Rex Grossman (10)
Matt Hasselbeck (10)
Brad Johnson (10)
Jon Kitna (10)
Byron Leftwich (10)
JP Losman (10)
Donovan McNabb (10)
Jake Plummer (10)
Chris Simms (10)
Alex Smith (10)
Billy Volek (10)
Charlie Frye (9)
Kurt Warner (8)
Eli Manning (8)
Drew Brees (8)
Michael Vick (6)
Peyton Manning (4)
Brett Favre (2)

Eliminated - Please do not Erase
Ben Roethlisberger
Steve McNair

[BoSox34]

Palmer is a better QB, but then again Big Ben did better than any other QB in the playoffs up until the SB. So don't sell him short. I don't think their is a significant difference between the two, yet. While Palmer is a better QB, its not by a large margin by any means.

+ Brett Favre
- Carson Palmer

Philip Rivers (16)
Carson Palmer (13)
Chad Pennington (11)
Tom Brady (11)
Jake Delhomme (11)
Aaron Brooks (10)
Mark Brunell (10)
Marc Bulger (10)
David Carr (10)
Daunte Culpepper (10)
Trent Green (10)
Rex Grossman (10)
Matt Hasselbeck (10)
Brad Johnson (10)
Jon Kitna (10)
Byron Leftwich (10)
JP Losman (10)
Donovan McNabb (10)
Jake Plummer (10)
Chris Simms (10)
Alex Smith (10)
Billy Volek (10)
Charlie Frye (9)
Kurt Warner (8)
Eli Manning (8)
Drew Brees (8)
Michael Vick (6)
Peyton Manning (4)
Brett Favre (3)

Eliminated - Please do not Erase
Ben Roethlisberger
Steve McNair