+ Roger Clemens
- Kei Igawa
Derek Jeter (28)
Alex Rodriguez (18)
Jorge Posada (15)
Andy Pettitte (15)
Chien-Ming Wang (14)
Philip Hughes (13)
Hideki Matsui (13)
Brian Bruney (12)
Sean Henn (12)
Melky Cabrera (11)
Brian Cashman (11)
Don Mattingly (11)
Chris Basak (10)
Andy Phillips (10)
Edwar Ramirez (10)
Mariano Rivera (10)
Kevin Thompson (10)
Kei Igawa(9)
Ron Villone (9)
Darrell Rasner (9)
Ron Guidry (8)
Kevin Long (8)
Mike Myers (8)
Roger Clemens(8)
George Steinbrenner (7)
Miguel Cairo (7)
Jeff Karstens (7)
Robinson Cano (6)
Johnny Damon (6)
Josh Phelps (6)
Bobby Abreu (6)
Scott Proctor (5)
Mike Mussina (5)
Wil Nieves (5)
Matt DeSalvo (3)
Eliminated:
Carl Pavano
Doug Mientkiewicz
Chase Wright
Colter Bean
Luis Vizcaino
Joe Torre
Jason Giambi
Kyle Farnsworth
Tyler "The Yankee" Clippard