Here's my thinking, let me know what you think:
Starting Lineup:
Jose Reyes
Luis Castillo
David Wright
Carlos Beltran
Carlos Delgado
Ryan Church
Angel Pagan/Endy Chavez
Brian Schneider
Pitcher
Bench:
Angel Pagan/Endy Chavez(whoever isn't starting)
Ramon Castro
Ruben Gotay
Marlon Anderson
Damion Easley
Anderson Hernandez(middle infield backup)
Rotation:
Johan Santana
Pedro Martinez
John Maine
Oliver Perez
hopefully, Mike Pelfrey
Bullpen:
Billy Wagner
Aaron Heilman
Pedro Feliciano
Steven Register
Matt Wise
El Duque