Catchers
Ramon Hernandez (Padres) - The perception that Hernandez quit on the Padres by not waiting until the offseason to undergo wrist surgery probably won’t have much of an impact on the contract he receives as a free agent. Just 28 years old, he’s the one catcher available worthy of a long-term commitment. The Padres are less likely to re-sign him now, but the Mets figure to be very interested and the Astros could use him, too. The two Los Angeles teams can’t be counted out, although both have prospects they shouldn’t be looking to block. Unless the wrist injury turns out to be more of a concern than currently anticipated, Hernandez will probably get a four-year deal. Prediction: Mets - four year, $26 million
Mike Piazza (Mets) - Back as a full-time catcher after a disastrous stint at first base in 2004, Piazza has done his usual fine job handling pitchers and poor job throwing out baserunners. With his OPS lingering right around 800 for the second straight season, it’s going to be very interesting to see what happens with him this winter. There won’t be a lot of interest in him as a regular catcher, but it’ll only take one team to make it happen. As a DH, he probably wouldn’t provide more production than some who would come much cheaper. A move to the Orioles, where he and Javy Lopez could share catching and DH duties, would make all kinds of sense. Prediction: Orioles - one year, $5 million
Bengie Molina (Angels) - Molina, making $3 million this year, is putting up the best numbers of his career at age 31. The Angels undoubtedly would like to bring him back for 2006, but Molina is probably going to want a three-year deal. Damian Miller got one last year and he was four years older than Molina. The Angels have Jeff Mathis, who will be ready by 2007 at the latest, and they also have to be concerned with Molina’s history of leg problems. Still, my guess is that they’ll pay the price to re-sign him anyway. The Astros, Mets and Padres could also be interested. Prediction: Angels - three years, $11 million
Other free agents: Brad Ausmus (Astros), Dan Wilson (Mariners), Todd Pratt (Phillies), Einar Diaz (Cardinals), Gary Bennett (Nationals), Chris Widger (White Sox), Kelly Stinnett (Diamondbacks), Benito Santiago (FA), Charles Johnson (FA), Paul Bako (Dodgers), John Flaherty (Yankees), Sandy Alomar Jr. (Rangers), Eddie Perez (Braves), Alberto Castillo (FA), Greg Myers (FA), Pat Borders (Mariners)
No one here is worthy of regular playing time these days, although Ausmus might find some poor GM interested in him as a starter.
Options
Todd Greene (Rockies) - $800,000 team option, $100,000 buyout
The Rockies seem pretty impressed with Danny Ardoin’s defense, so Greene’s option is less likely to be picked up. There should be other teams willing to employ him as a backup.
Trade candidates: Johnny Estrada (Braves), Jason LaRue (Reds), Mike Lieberthal (Phillies), Toby Hall (Devil Rays), Rod Barajas (Rangers), Jason Phillips (Dodgers), Kelly Shoppach (Red Sox), Gerald Laird (Rangers), Javier Valentin (Reds), Josh Willingham (Marlins)
The Braves will probably want to keep Estrada for 2006, but selling while he still has quite a bit of value is recommended. If they wait until they’re positive Brian McCann is ready, they probably won’t get as much talent in return. … LaRue figures to make $4.5 million or more in his final year of arbitration eligibility. Javier Valentin’s breakthrough season might make him expendable. It’s unlikely the Reds will pay what it takes to keep both. … The Phillies will try and likely fail to find a taker for Lieberthal, whose $7.5 million option for 2006 kicked in earlier this season. … Texas doesn’t figure to keep both Barajas and Laird for another year. If the Rangers choose to commit to Barajas, there would be a few teams interested in making Laird a regular.
Non-tender candidates: Vance Wilson (Tigers), Geronimo Gil (Orioles), Wiki Gonzalez (Mariners), Adam Melhuse (Athletics), Chad Moeller (Brewers), Josh Paul (Angels)
Nothing but backups. … The Tigers seem to like Wilson, but if he wants more than a minimal raise over the $760,000 he’s making, he should be let go. … Gonzalez is making $1.2 million in the final year of the multiyear contract he signed with the Padres, so he’ll almost surely be made a free agent.
Top 2006 free agents: Jorge Posada (Yankees)*, Javy Lopez (Orioles), A.J. Pierzynski (White Sox), Jason LaRue (Reds), Mike Lieberthal (Phillies), Damian Miller (Brewers)*, Rod Barajas (Rangers), Gregg Zaun (Blue Jays), Doug Mirabelli (Red Sox), Mike Redmond (Twins)
The Yankees hold a $12 million option with a $4 million buyout on Posada for 2007. … If the $3.75 million team option is declined, Miller can return to the Brewers in 2007 for $2.25 million plus the chance to earn $750,000 in incentives.
First Basemen/Designated Hitters
Paul Konerko (White Sox) - Konerko is on pace for a second straight 40-homer season and he’s only turning 30 in March. He’ll almost certainly get a raise from the $8.75 million he’s making in the final season of a three-year deal he signed prior to 2003. Either four years and $40 million or three and $32 million would be appropriate. With Carlos Lee gone and Frank Thomas likely to depart, expect the White Sox to re-sign their first baseman. The Yankees, Orioles and Mets could pounce on him if the White Sox don’t move quickly. Prediction: White Sox - four years, $40 million
Erubiel Durazo (Athletics) - Durazo underwent Tommy John surgery in July, but he’ll probably be ready for the start of next season and some team should be willing to sign him as a DH. He’s a career .281/.381/.487 hitter and he’s not someone who needs to be platooned. A return to Oakland is fairly unlikely, although the club will be in the market for a DH if Scott Hatteberg isn’t re-signed. Durazo isn’t someone who figures to remain a good player into his mid-30s, but he has a chance to be a bargain signing for 2006. If the teams in need of a full-time DH pass him over, the Red Sox or Yankees would find a way to squeeze him in. Prediction: Yankees - one year, $2.5 million
Rafael Palmeiro (Orioles) - Palmeiro’s performance on his way to 3,000 hits made it look like he might be back for another year, but after the steroids suspension, it seems a lot more likely now that he’ll retire. Unless some new facts come to light, there won’t be a lot of demand for him. It might be Tampa Bay or nothing. Prediction: Retirement
Kevin Millar (Red Sox) - Barring some postseason heroics, Millar is about done in Boston. His lack of power has been a major problem this year, and he certainly doesn’t make up for it with his defense. The Red Sox may already have a superior option at first base on the roster in Roberto Petagine and there will be plenty of trade possibilities out there in the offseason. Millar’s newfound rep as a winner and a good clubhouse guy will likely make him a starter somewhere. Giving him a multiyear contract would be a very bad idea. Prediction: Orioles - one year, $3 million
Other free agents: Daryle Ward (Pirates), Travis Lee (Devil Rays), Olmedo Saenz (Dodgers), J.T. Snow (Giants), Jeff Conine (Marlins), Julio Franco (Braves), Mark Sweeney (Padres), Eduardo Perez (Devil Rays), John Olerud (Red Sox), Brad Fullmer (FA), Dave Hansen (Mariners), Jose Offerman (Mets), Carlos Baerga (Nationals), Wil Cordero (Mets), Lenny Harris (Marlins)
Some useful players, but there’s no one here guaranteed of entering next year as a regular. Saenz will be the subject of a lot of interest as a bench player. Lee might have a starting job, depending on how he finishes up.
Options
Dmitri Young (Tigers) - $8 million team option vests with 500 plate appearances
Frank Thomas (White Sox) - $12 million team option; $10 million player option with $3.5 million buyout
Doug Mientkiewicz (Mets) - $3.75 million team option, $450,000 buyout
Tino Martinez (Yankees) - $3 million team option, $250,000 buyout
Scott Hatteberg (Athletics) - $2.7 million-$2.8 million team option, unknown buyout
Young’s option will kick in with another 78 plate appearances. The Tigers won’t sit him down to avoid the commitment, but if he does get hurt again, it’s possible the option won’t be picked up. … The White Sox will probably save themselves $6.5 million and set Thomas free. There’s some optimism, but it’s hardly guaranteed that Thomas will be healthy at the start of the season. He’s likely to depart Chicago for an incentive-laden one-year deal elsewhere. … Injuries have hurt Mientkiewicz’s chances of having his option picked up. The Mets will try to upgrade at first base. … Martinez and Hatteberg should both have their options declined, although they could be re-signed at lesser prices.
Trade candidates: Lyle Overbay (Brewers), Chad Tracy (Diamondbacks), Ryan Howard (Phillies), Mike Sweeney (Royals), Eric Hinske (Blue Jays), Hee Seop Choi (Dodgers), Jim Thome (Phillies), Todd Helton (Rockies), Sean Casey (Reds), Darin Erstad (Angels), Jeff Bagwell (Astros), Phil Nevin (Rangers), Ben Broussard (Indians), Adrian Gonzalez (Rangers), Ryan Shealy (Rockies), Jason Stokes (Marlins), Brandon Sing (Cubs)
It’s appearing more likely that Prince Fielder will be ready to help the Brewers next season, and even though Overbay hasn’t been all that good over the last three months, that he’s not going to be a free agent until after 2008 makes him very attractive. … Tracy has outplayed Overbay of late and is expendable because of Conor Jackson and Carlos Quentin. The Diamondbacks should move him while his value is at its highest.
Of the higher priced players, Sweeney is probably still the best bet to go, although the Rangers should try hard to move Nevin. Dumping Thome may be impossible for the Phillies now. … Bagwell’s shoulder could force him into retirement. If he wants to keep playing, the Astros may have to eat his contract and send him to an AL team so he can be used as a DH.
Non-tender candidates: Carlos Pena (Tigers), Josh Phelps (Devil Rays), Mike Lamb (Astros)
Pena is making $2.575 million this season and is eligible for arbitration once again, so he’ll likely have to be released rather than traded. He’d be a good pickup for a small-market club.
Top 2006 free agents: Derrek Lee (Cubs), Nick Johnson (Nationals), Darin Erstad (Angels), Shea Hillenbrand (Blue Jays), Sean Casey (Reds), Phil Nevin (Rangers), Scott Spiezio (Mariners)*
Lee has put himself in position to be next winter’s top free agent. The Cubs will probably discuss a new contract with him this winter. … Spiezio figures to be released long before the Mariners need to make a decision on his option for 2007.
Second Basemen
Craig Biggio (Astros) - Biggio hasn’t been especially impressive defensively in his return to the infield, but he appears to be on his way to his best season offensively since 2001. It’d be an upset if the Astros didn’t keep him and leave him at second base for one more year. Chris Burke can remain in the outfield or become trade bait. Prediction: Astros - one year, $3.5 million
Mark Grudzielanek (Cardinals) - The Cardinals aren’t only pleased with what Grudzielanek has brought to the table offensively, but they think he deserves Gold Glove consideration. Best of all is that it looks like he’ll stay off the disabled list for the first time in three years. He’s put himself in position to receive a multiyear deal, even with the Yankees not likely to be interested. It seems likely that he’ll stay in St. Louis, although the Rangers, Twins, Giants and Devil Rays are among the clubs that could be interested in him. Prediction: Cardinals - two years, $5 million
Bret Boone (FA) - Boone is expected to come back and give it another try next year. Some team will probably be willing to guarantee him money, no matter how helpless he looked at the end with the Twins. Prediction: Devil Rays - one year, $1.5 million
Other free agents: Tony Graffanino (Red Sox), Miguel Cairo (Mets), Deivi Cruz (Giants), Damion Easley (Marlins), Fernando Vina (Tigers), Joe McEwing (Royals)
Graffanino’s OBP will make him a target of several teams and it’s possible that he’ll land a starting job. Cairo, Cruz and Easley should have utility roles.
Options
Ray Durham (Giants) - $7 million player option
Ronnie Belliard (Indians) - $4 million team option, $500,000 buyout
Mark Loretta (Padres) - $3 million team option vests at 293 plate appearances
Todd Walker (Cubs) - $2.5 million-$2.75 million team option vests at unknown number of PAs
Frank Menechino (Blue Jays) - $775,000 team option vests at 340 plate appearances, $50,000 buyout
Durham’s bat is still there, but since injuries are taking him out of the lineup so frequently and making him a liability on defense, he’s going to have to exercise his option to return to the Giants. He could be traded. … Belliard’s solid work, combined with Brandon Phillips’ lack of progress, should result in his option being picked up. … Loretta will stay in San Diego regardless of whether the option kicks in automatically. … The Cubs will also likely bring Walker back to play second base for one more year.
Trade candidates: Alfonso Soriano (Rangers), Marcus Giles (Braves), Orlando Hudson (Blue Jays), Jerry Hairston Jr. (Cubs), Ray Durham (Giants), Junior Spivey (Nationals), Omar Infante (Tigers), Kaz Matsui (Mets), Tony Womack (Yankees), Keith Ginter (Athletics), Alex Cora (Red Sox), Chris Burke (Astros), Antonio Perez (Dodgers), Brandon Phillips (Indians)
Soriano will make about $10 million in his final year of arbitration eligibility, so expect more trade rumors this winter. … The Blue Jays might trade Hudson to open up second base for Aaron Hill. Hudson’s outstanding glove would lead to plenty of interest if he’s available. … Hairston is one of the 30 best second basemen in the majors. The Cubs should trade him rather than make him a part-time player in the outfield once again. … Infante figures to be made available by the Tigers with Placido Polanco locked up for four years. He’s only turning 24 in December, so he should have a future as a long-term regular.
Non-tender candidates: Mark Bellhorn (Red Sox), D’Angelo Jimenez (Reds), Luis Rivas (Twins), Marlon Anderson (Mets), Willie Harris (White Sox), Willie Bloomquist (Mariners), Henry Mateo (Nationals)
If Bellhorn accepts a salary reduction, the Red Sox may look to re-sign him and let him compete with Dustin Pedroia for a starting job. But that’s assuming he isn’t released before the end of the season. … Jimenez will likely have to settle for a utility role after being banished to Double-A by the Reds. … Rivas belongs in Triple-A, but a lesser team will sign him and let him compete for a starting job. … The Mets will likely want to keep Anderson on their bench, but if he insists on going to arbitration, he could be let go.
Top 2006 free agents: Alfonso Soriano (Rangers), Jeff Kent (Dodgers), Luis Castillo (Marlins)*, Adam Kennedy (Angels), Jerry Hairston Jr. (Cubs), Ray Durham (Giants), Ronnie Belliard (Indians), Craig Counsell (Diamondbacks), Junior Spivey (Nationals)
By the time next winter rolls around, Soriano, Kent, Hairston and Durham may all be looked at as potential regulars at other positions. Soriano, at least, may continue to insist on remaining at second base. … The 2007 option on Castillo’s contract is worth $5.75 million and includes a $500,000 buyout.