A Baseball Slant Poll

[Slyder]

I just wanted to post two careers and see the results. You can PM me after you vote if you want to know who's who and if you know who's who please don't spoil it.

Also sorry if it comes up small if an admin knows how to enlarge it to be seen please feel free to do so.

[Kingdom]

Love that it took me 5 seconds to figure out who's who.

[Hammer]

Love that it took me 5 seconds to figure out who's who.

yea really. regardless, aside from doubles, player 2... how fitting... is clearly the better ball player on numbers alone.

[Kingdom]

Both are hall of fame dudes, or should be, but I'll take should be hall guy 2.

[HollywoodLeo]

They're both very comparable, and without having figured out who player 1 is just yet I wonder if that's the point trying to be made here? (Since I'm sure the obvious consensus amongst everyone is player 2 is an easy HOFer).

But if you twist my arm, even just going off the statistics presented, I'd take player 2.

[HollywoodLeo]

As a sidebar, that could be a fun game. Guess the player by the stat line.

[Kingdom]

Once you figure out player 1, the likely point of the poll makes sense

[HollywoodLeo]

Yeah, I was right.

[Tobywan]

Love 'em both, but #2.

[LJMets1989]

I'd say both, but there's a clear gap between the two, with #2 on top. I figured out who #2 was quickly, had to google to find out #1.

[Mach]

for better or worse, postseason matters too though.

[cjkalt]

Can someone pm me who players areTy

[Trendy Bastard]

How is both even an option

[HollywoodLeo]

He meant to ask if either or both or none were first ballot
HOFers

[Witlon]

Well, in a pure numbers sense, player B is obviously better, stat wise.

Player A was the best hitter at his position for a lot of his career, though, something that player B can't say.