cleveland-tampa BAY

[nick]

Originally Posted by Shadow29
Cleveland send:
SP C.C. Sabathia 3.0 8.2 mil
2B Abstrubal Cabrera 5.0P MLC
MR Jansen Lewis 5.0P 300k
CF Grady Sizemore 3.0 5.122 mil
3 Mil in cash

TB sends:
SS B.J Upton 5.0P 300K
SP Nicholas Barnese 5.0P MLC
C Chad Tracey 4.0P MLC
SS Rod Broniac 5.0P MLC (Seriously 5.0???)
2B marcus Giles, 2.5 stars, 3.3 mil

[nick]

- an MLB-ready SS who can easily step in for upton... with 9 contact, 7 power... in cabrera.. 5.0 spect, at that
-10-9-9 frontline starter
-leadoff hitter who plays gold glove defense, and in all regards is about equal to bj... all things considered.
-middle reliever.. nothing special, but hes young and filled out

for..

-aweosme 4-tool player, would be 5-tool but he cant play a lick of D... probably the best player in the deal, if he could play defense
-10th best prospect rated by the game in the TB system.. 10-7-8, but still pretty damn solid. nonetheless, for sabbathia alone i'd want two or three pieces like this, let alone sabbathia AND sizemore... but with bj included, i'd want atleast one more top-line spect like Barnese instead of crap like Tracey and Brignac
-tracey sucks dick
-brignac really sucks for a 5.0 spect
-marcus giles is salary


At this point I think I'd fail... but I'm not sure really.

[Hammer]

im cool with like barnese and tracy for cc... sizemore and asdrubal for upton and brignac... and lewis and cash for giles. so pass ahoy.

[bjd2933]

I'm undecided... i've never been a huge fan of big trades... I'll look it over tonight

[browntown653]

fail, tampa needs to add another spect

[Providence A's]

Originally Posted by Shadow29
Cleveland send:
SP C.C. Sabathia 3.0 8.2 mil
2B Abstrubal Cabrera 5.0P MLC
MR Jansen Lewis 5.0P 300k
CF Grady Sizemore 3.0 5.122 mil
3 Mil in cash

TB sends:
SS B.J Upton 5.0P 300K
SP Nicholas Barnese 5.0P MLC
C Chad Tracey 4.0P MLC
SS Rod Broniac 5.0P MLC (Seriously 5.0???)
2B marcus Giles, 2.5 stars, 3.3 mil

Who the hell typed this up? It's Asdrubal and Reid Brignac. That being said, I think Cleveland is giving up waaaaaaay too much here. Fail.

[Kingdom]

Oh, fail by a mile. I'd maybe pass it if it was just CC and ..Cabrera or Lewis. Ridiculous deal here, surprising from Shadow.

[bjd2933]

I'm gonna fail this one... Cleveland is getting it up the butt.

[nick]

yeah, i woudl've failed too.

[Kingdom]

We need votes on the chicago deal