oak - phi

[Providence A's]

Oakland Trades:

OF Javier Herrera - 4.5 star spec - MLC
SP Jason Windsor - 3.5 star spec - MLC

Philadelphia Trades:

SP Carlos Carrasco - 5.0 star spec - MLC

[Kingdom]

Witlon must be desperate to unload this prospect..? Eh, I do not like Herrera at all.

[Providence A's]

They're both A ball specs (Herrera and Carassco)...Windsor is close and still has room to grow.

[BrianDawkins]

aww you sum*****, you beat out my offer

[Providence A's]

is that a fail and a pass? or a comment and comment...?

[Kingdom]

mines a pass, but philly is still stupid for doing it

[nick]

ehh.. Herrera is good, but he's kinda underdeveloped and prone (not a huge deal there though).

Winsdor I like, but still. Carrasco is a beast... top-15 in the league easily.

On the other hand, Witlon has all the pitching in the world it seems.. starting inparticular. And just traded Bourne to my knowledge. So I can see where he might want an OF spect now.

I'm on the fence here... I'll let some others vote, unless my vote is needed.

[Providence A's]

so a pass, a ???, and a on the fence...

[nick]

I think tim's is a pass too, but I'm not sure. Let him confirm it first...

[Hammer]

windsor is good enough to make up the difference between carrasco and herrera, pass it.

[Providence A's]

2 passes, a ???, and a on the fence...c'mon 1 more pass.

[Providence A's]

c'mon...vote please....or if Bdawk confirms that he passed, then this would be all set.

[BrianDawkins]

oh shit yea, i'm sorry. gotta check my subscribed threads more often.

this is a pass by me, sorry for the delay

[Providence A's]

cool...passes 3 - 0.