I got NCAA. I like it since I created my high school team on there. But I won't be playing it much once I get a new MLB game. I don't really like either of the options out there, but MLB 2K6 looks to be the better one for me. I really don't like the way the MLB "The Show" graphics look. Unless all the trailers on it are for PS1, and I doubt that.
Does anyone know if either of the games will have minor leagues that we can actually play with like in MVP?