JMjr, S3SL Hall of Fame worthy?

[Kingdom]

I mentioned Michel.

Pitts and Sato would make the hall of good, nothing more. Neither are really close to any of the big milestones, neither even have 2000 hits or 400 homeruns.

[Porter]

If you menton Keifer and Peppers in the under 30 crowd.

#69 Daniel Saunders, Starting Pitcher, 28 yrs, Arizona Diamondbacks - Out of the Park Baseball Report

74 wins in the last 4 seasons.

[Kingdom]

Because they both have a 100 or more wins, and also have a better ERA than Saunders.

[Porter]

I mentioned Michel.

Pitts and Sato would make the hall of good, nothing more. Neither are really close to any of the big milestones, neither even have 2000 hits or 400 homeruns.

I agree with that. Thats why if Pitts ever got in, then Sato would have too.

[browntown653]

Since nobody responded, I'm going to assume you'd all put Rybicki in.

[Dry1313]

Keifer and Pitts? I raise you Montoya and Witcher.


Also, Hamburg would be there if he didn't get raped that one year...he's still perhaps worthy

[Saber]

I wouldn't put Rybicki in.

[Porter]

Because they both have a 100 or more wins, and also have a better ERA than Saunders.

They both pitched in more starts. And Keifer has a grand .05 ERA advantage over Saunders. And unlike Kiefer, he can win a playoff game.

Wins in the last 4
Keifer = 77
Peppers and Saunders = 74

If you add the postseason.
Saunders and Keifer = 77
Peppers = 75

Im not saying Peppers or Keifer are better, but Saunders deserves to be in the argument

[Kingdom]

He's behind on wins. His chances at 200 or more are slim to none. That's the whole point. If a good team trades for Keifer, he's going to make a run unless his talent fades from a coke addiction.

Witcher- not even close. At 33, not even 1000 hits or 300 homeruns

Montoya- maybe because he has a shot at 500 since he routinely hits the high 30's and mid 40's in homeruns, but the rest of his numbers kinda suck

[Kingdom]

Since nobody responded, I'm going to assume you'd all put Rybicki in.

Outside chance but if he continues to live up to the power ratings, he has 6-7 years maybe to smack 230 homeruns. It's possible, especially if he has a flukey 50 homerun year and Arlington is a good park for homeruns. He could also hit 3000 hits, since he's about 1300 away and has a high contact rating.

[browntown653]

I think 3000 hits is a solid bet for him.

[Porter]

#39 Ramon "Hillbilly" Crespo, Starting Pitcher, 29 yrs, Houston Astros - Out of the Park Baseball Report