Nominations for the best 16 players in M's History.

[Porter]

Who do you think is the best 16 players in M's History

Heres some nominations

Ken Griffey Jr
Ichiro Suzuki
Alex Rodriguez
Alvin Davis
Mark Langston
Randy Johnson
Jamie Moyer
Kaz Sasaki
Jim Pressley
Harold Reynolds
Freddy Garcia
Phil Bradley
Edgar Martinez
John Olerud
Jay Buhner
Tino Martinez

Any you want to omit....add to the list? Make Suggestions it will be finalized in 1 week from today.

For those not famliar with all time stats

All Time Leaders Hitting

All Time Leaders Pitching

[awefullspellare]

One suggestion is to post stats for all of the players when you run it. Will help those of us without a great knowledge of the M's. Also, are we using only stats from during the M's career of these players or all time?

I'll definitely vote on these .

[General]

Take Tino offa there.

[Porter]

Its for time they played with the M's.

General: who to take his spot.

[General]

Why 16? Personally, 15 is a much better number.

[Porter]

16 is an even number thats why.

[awefullspellare]

16 you can do a tournament dealio, 15 is odd.

[Porter]

Those Stats are before this season, and as a Mariner.

[MarinersFan87]

I'd take Tino off and put Boone on there. I know he sucks now, but in 2001 he was the man, he deserved the MVP more than Ich probably. He had a nice run here and his defense was always gold glove caliber.

[Porter]

I'd take Tino off and put Boone on there. I know he sucks now, but in 2001 he was the man, he deserved the MVP more than Ich probably. He had a nice run here and his defense was always gold glove caliber.

Im torn between the 2 people. cause both helped out the club. and in short stints too.

[MarinersFan87]

I think it comes down to in the 4 years that Tino really contributed here the most games the M's ever won was 82. Boone was one of our two best hitters for 3 years from 01-03 when we won 116, 93, and 93 games.

[Porter]

point taken....although i think they won 85 games in 95. but you do have a point.

Boone for Tino.

[General]

Yeah, I didn't notice Boone wasn't on there.

[MarinersFan87]

I think these are definetely the right 16. Do you plan on ranking them in order to make the tourney fair, so we don't get Jr. vs. RJ in the first round or something like that?

[love_that_reefer]

Omar Vizquel started his career there as did Dave Henderson. Ken Phelps had some good years there.