All Time San Francisco Giants Team

[SF Kid]

Thought it would be fun to see what peolpe think should be the ALL TIME SAN FRANCISCO GIANTS team...

Here are the postions we'll name:

1B
2B
3B
SS
C
OF
OF
OF
RHP
LHP
PINCH HITTER
RELIEF PITCHER

Here is my all time SF Giants team...

1B - Willie McCovey
2B - Jeff Kent
3B - Matt Williams
SS - Jose Pagan
C - Tom Haller
OF - Willie Mays
OF - Barry Bonds
OF - Orlando Cepeda
RHP - Juan Marichal
LHP - Kirk Rueter
Pinch Hitter - Jimmy Ray Hart
Relief Pitcher - Rob Nen

What's your all Time SF Giants Team?...

[DirtyKash]

1B - Willie McCovey
2B - Jeff Kent
3B - Matt Williams
SS - Jose Pagan
OF - Willie Mays
OF - Barry Bonds
OF - Orlando Cepeda
RHP - Juan Marichal
LHP - Kirk Rueter
Pinch Hitter - Jimmy Ray Hart
Relief Pitcher - Rob Nen

Where's your catcher

[love_that_reefer]

1B-McCovey
2B-Kent
SS-Aurilia
3B-Williams
OF-Bonds
OF-Mays
OF-Ott
C-Manwaring?
RHP-Marichal
LHP-Hubbell
Pinch Hitter-Jack Clark
Relief-Nen

[DirtyKash]

Just off the top of my head, I have a HARD time coming up with any decent Giants catcher. I have to brush up on my trivia before the forum game starts, damn.

[love_that_reefer]

I say Manwaring because he was a good defensive catcher who came up with bighits and he gave me his batting glove

[love_that_reefer]

Also I just realized that the thread said SAN FRANCISCO Giants and I will be penalized for some of my picks.

[DirtyKash]

Probably have to go with Bob Brenly, but ugh...

[love_that_reefer]

Brenly was a goofy looking son of a ***** behind the plate. He was like 175 and playing catcher. Not a bad pick though. He will be managing again soon, possibly when Baker leaves Chitown.

[Bear]

THIS IS MY ALL TIME SAN FRANCISCO TEAM!!

RHP - Juan Marichal
LHP- Mike McCormick
C. - Mike Matheny
1B. - Willie McCovey
2B. - Jeff Kent
3B. - Matt Williams
SS. - Omar Vizquel
LF. - Barry Bonds
CF. - Willie Mays
RF. - Bobby Bonds
Pinch Hitter RH - Orlando Cepeda
Pinch Hitter LH - Will Clark
Relief Pitcher - Rob Nen

NOTE: MEL OTT NEVER PLAYED IN S.F.

[DirtyKash]

Mike Matheny???

[realmofotalk]

Where's the love for A.J. Pierzynski?

[DirtyKash]

Can I get a BOBBY ESTALELLA?!? WOOT WOOT!

[Bear]

When I chose Mike Matheny as my catcher it was for more than one reason. First the Giants have not had a great hitter in that position since they moved from NY. Second he is one of the beat handlers of pitchers in the game, and this is a position that is not just about how well you hit. JMO

[SF Kid]

Ooops....Catcher - Tom Haller

[SF Kid]

I'd say Tom Haller had the best career at catcher of anyone that played a decent amount of time in San Francisco.

Take a look

Also, although Cepeda wasn't very good in LF, I had to have him in the lineup. One of the greatest Giants of ALL TIME. Found myself in the same dilemma that the Giants were in themselves trying to get Willie Mc and Orlando in the lineup at the same time. Heck, even Willie had a stint in LF. That was ugly.