+ Hoffman
- Ray
Francisco Rodriguez (14)
Trevor Hoffman (12)
J.J. Putz (11)
B.J. Ryan (10)
Joe Borowski (10)
Tom Gordon (10)
Ryan Dempster (10)
Brad Lidge (10)
Francisco Cordero (10)
Mike Gonzalez (10)
Jason Isringhausen (10)
Jorge Julio (10)
Armando Benitez (10)
Brian Fuentes (10)
Eddie Guardado (9)
Chad Cordero (9)
Billy Wagner (9)
Seth McClung (9)
Todd Jones (9)
Joe Nelson (9)
Akinori Otsuka (9)
Huston Street (9)
Tom Mastny (7)
Takashi Saito (6)
Chris Ray (4)
Joe Nathan (1)
Eliminated
Jonathan Papelbon
Mariano Rivera
Bobby Jenks
Bob Wickman