RB elimination game (read the rules)

[DirtyKash]

Rules for this game:
Add 1 point for every plus
Subtract 2 points for every minus

Only RBs who are first on the depth chart, or else we'll never finish.

+ Ahman Green
- Chester Taylor

Ahman Green (11)
Willis McGahee (10)
Ronnie Brown (10)
Corey Dillon (10)
Lee Suggs (10)
Jamal Lewis (10)
Rudi Johnson (10)
Reuben Droughns (10)
Willie Parker (10)
Domanick Davis (10)
Dominic Rhodes (10)
Fred Taylor (10)
Chris Brown (10)
Mike Bell (10)
Larry Johnson (10)
Lamont Jordan (10)
LaDainian Tomlinson (10)
Julius Jones (10)
Tiki Barber (10)
Brian Westbrook (10)
Clinton Portis (10)
Cedric Benson (10)
Kevin Jones (10)
Warrick Dunn (10)
DeShaun Foster (10)
Deuce McAllister (10)
Carnell Williams (10)
Edgerrin James (10)
Shaun Alexander (10)
Frank Gore (10)
Steven Jackson (10)
Chester Taylor (8)

[General]

+ Tiki
- Shaun Alexander
Tiki Barber (11)
Ahman Green (11)
Willis McGahee (10)
Ronnie Brown (10)
Corey Dillon (10)
Lee Suggs (10)
Jamal Lewis (10)
Rudi Johnson (10)
Reuben Droughns (10)
Willie Parker (10)
Domanick Davis (10)
Dominic Rhodes (10)
Fred Taylor (10)
Chris Brown (10)
Mike Bell (10)
Larry Johnson (10)
Lamont Jordan (10)
LaDainian Tomlinson (10)
Julius Jones (10)
Brian Westbrook (10)
Clinton Portis (10)
Cedric Benson (10)
Kevin Jones (10)
Warrick Dunn (10)
DeShaun Foster (10)
Deuce McAllister (10)
Carnell Williams (10)
Edgerrin James (10)
Frank Gore (10)
Steven Jackson (10)
Chester Taylor (8)
Shaun Alexander (8)

[Lynch]

+ Edgerrin James
- Ahman Green

Tiki Barber (11)
Edgerrin James (11)
Willis McGahee (10)
Ronnie Brown (10)
Corey Dillon (10)
Lee Suggs (10)
Jamal Lewis (10)
Rudi Johnson (10)
Reuben Droughns (10)
Willie Parker (10)
Domanick Davis (10)
Dominic Rhodes (10)
Fred Taylor (10)
Chris Brown (10)
Mike Bell (10)
Larry Johnson (10)
Lamont Jordan (10)
LaDainian Tomlinson (10)
Julius Jones (10)
Brian Westbrook (10)
Clinton Portis (10)
Cedric Benson (10)
Kevin Jones (10)
Warrick Dunn (10)
DeShaun Foster (10)
Deuce McAllister (10)
Carnell Williams (10)
Frank Gore (10)
Steven Jackson (10)
Ahman Green (9)
Chester Taylor (8)
Shaun Alexander (8)

[DirtyKash]

+ LaDainian
- Shaun Alexander

Tiki Barber (11)
LaDainian Tomlinson (11)
Edgerrin James (11)
Willis McGahee (10)
Ronnie Brown (10)
Corey Dillon (10)
Lee Suggs (10)
Jamal Lewis (10)
Rudi Johnson (10)
Reuben Droughns (10)
Willie Parker (10)
Domanick Davis (10)
Dominic Rhodes (10)
Fred Taylor (10)
Chris Brown (10)
Mike Bell (10)
Larry Johnson (10)
Lamont Jordan (10)
Julius Jones (10)
Brian Westbrook (10)
Clinton Portis (10)
Cedric Benson (10)
Kevin Jones (10)
Warrick Dunn (10)
DeShaun Foster (10)
Deuce McAllister (10)
Carnell Williams (10)
Frank Gore (10)
Steven Jackson (10)
Ahman Green (9)
Chester Taylor (8)
Shaun Alexander (6)

[Lynch]

+ James
- Green

Edgerrin James (12)
Tiki Barber (11)
LaDainian Tomlinson (11)
Willis McGahee (10)
Ronnie Brown (10)
Corey Dillon (10)
Lee Suggs (10)
Jamal Lewis (10)
Rudi Johnson (10)
Reuben Droughns (10)
Willie Parker (10)
Domanick Davis (10)
Dominic Rhodes (10)
Fred Taylor (10)
Chris Brown (10)
Mike Bell (10)
Larry Johnson (10)
Lamont Jordan (10)
Julius Jones (10)
Brian Westbrook (10)
Clinton Portis (10)
Cedric Benson (10)
Kevin Jones (10)
Warrick Dunn (10)
DeShaun Foster (10)
Deuce McAllister (10)
Carnell Williams (10)
Frank Gore (10)
Steven Jackson (10)
Chester Taylor (8)
Ahman Green (7)
Shaun Alexander (6)

[Rufio181]

+ LT
- Alexander (overrated with that Seattle o-line)

LaDainian Tomlinson (12)
Edgerrin James (12)
Tiki Barber (11)
Willis McGahee (10)
Ronnie Brown (10)
Corey Dillon (10)
Lee Suggs (10)
Jamal Lewis (10)
Rudi Johnson (10)
Reuben Droughns (10)
Willie Parker (10)
Domanick Davis (10)
Dominic Rhodes (10)
Fred Taylor (10)
Chris Brown (10)
Mike Bell (10)
Larry Johnson (10)
Lamont Jordan (10)
Julius Jones (10)
Brian Westbrook (10)
Clinton Portis (10)
Cedric Benson (10)
Kevin Jones (10)
Warrick Dunn (10)
DeShaun Foster (10)
Deuce McAllister (10)
Carnell Williams (10)
Frank Gore (10)
Steven Jackson (10)
Chester Taylor (8)
Ahman Green (7)
Shaun Alexander (4)

[olypride09]

+ Shaun (you all just hate him cause you don't have him)
- Edge (Playin for ARI is gonna bring his #'s down)

LaDainian Tomlinson (12)
Edgerrin James (10)
Tiki Barber (11)
Willis McGahee (10)
Ronnie Brown (10)
Corey Dillon (10)
Lee Suggs (10)
Jamal Lewis (10)
Rudi Johnson (10)
Reuben Droughns (10)
Willie Parker (10)
Domanick Davis (10)
Dominic Rhodes (10)
Fred Taylor (10)
Chris Brown (10)
Mike Bell (10)
Larry Johnson (10)
Lamont Jordan (10)
Julius Jones (10)
Brian Westbrook (10)
Clinton Portis (10)
Cedric Benson (10)
Kevin Jones (10)
Warrick Dunn (10)
DeShaun Foster (10)
Deuce McAllister (10)
Carnell Williams (10)
Frank Gore (10)
Steven Jackson (10)
Chester Taylor (8)
Ahman Green (7)
Shaun Alexander (5)

[DirtyKash]

+ LT
- Alexander

LaDainian Tomlinson (13)
Tiki Barber (11)
Edgerrin James (10)
Willis McGahee (10)
Ronnie Brown (10)
Corey Dillon (10)
Lee Suggs (10)
Jamal Lewis (10)
Rudi Johnson (10)
Reuben Droughns (10)
Willie Parker (10)
Domanick Davis (10)
Dominic Rhodes (10)
Fred Taylor (10)
Chris Brown (10)
Mike Bell (10)
Larry Johnson (10)
Lamont Jordan (10)
Julius Jones (10)
Brian Westbrook (10)
Clinton Portis (10)
Cedric Benson (10)
Kevin Jones (10)
Warrick Dunn (10)
DeShaun Foster (10)
Deuce McAllister (10)
Carnell Williams (10)
Frank Gore (10)
Steven Jackson (10)
Chester Taylor (8)
Ahman Green (7)
Shaun Alexander (3)

[Raphictor]

+ JJ
- Gore

LaDainian Tomlinson (13)
Tiki Barber (11)
Julius Jones (11)
Edgerrin James (10)
Willis McGahee (10)
Ronnie Brown (10)
Corey Dillon (10)
Lee Suggs (10)
Jamal Lewis (10)
Rudi Johnson (10)
Reuben Droughns (10)
Willie Parker (10)
Domanick Davis (10)
Dominic Rhodes (10)
Fred Taylor (10)
Chris Brown (10)
Mike Bell (10)
Larry Johnson (10)
Lamont Jordan (10)
Brian Westbrook (10)
Clinton Portis (10)
Cedric Benson (10)
Kevin Jones (10)
Warrick Dunn (10)
DeShaun Foster (10)
Deuce McAllister (10)
Carnell Williams (10)
Steven Jackson (10)
Chester Taylor (8)
Frank Gore (8)
Ahman Green (7)
Shaun Alexander (3)

[Mr. D™]

+ Rudi Rudi Rudi Rudi Rudi Rudi
- Jamal Lewis

LaDainian Tomlinson (13)
Tiki Barber (11)
Julius Jones (11)
Rudi Johnson (11)
Edgerrin James (10)
Willis McGahee (10)
Ronnie Brown (10)
Corey Dillon (10)
Lee Suggs (10)
Reuben Droughns (10)
Willie Parker (10)
Domanick Davis (10)
Dominic Rhodes (10)
Fred Taylor (10)
Chris Brown (10)
Mike Bell (10)
Larry Johnson (10)
Lamont Jordan (10)
Brian Westbrook (10)
Clinton Portis (10)
Cedric Benson (10)
Kevin Jones (10)
Warrick Dunn (10)
DeShaun Foster (10)
Deuce McAllister (10)
Carnell Williams (10)
Steven Jackson (10)
Jamal Lewis (8)
Chester Taylor (8)
Frank Gore (8)
Ahman Green (7)
Shaun Alexander (3)

[Lynch]

(pretty ****ing sad if Alexander gets voted off first. If he does, this elimination game will be equally as worthless as the firstbaseman game when one of the best was voted off immediately)


+ Alexander
- Green

LaDainian Tomlinson (13)
Tiki Barber (11)
Julius Jones (11)
Rudi Johnson (11)
Edgerrin James (10)
Willis McGahee (10)
Ronnie Brown (10)
Corey Dillon (10)
Lee Suggs (10)
Reuben Droughns (10)
Willie Parker (10)
Domanick Davis (10)
Dominic Rhodes (10)
Fred Taylor (10)
Chris Brown (10)
Mike Bell (10)
Larry Johnson (10)
Lamont Jordan (10)
Brian Westbrook (10)
Clinton Portis (10)
Cedric Benson (10)
Kevin Jones (10)
Warrick Dunn (10)
DeShaun Foster (10)
Deuce McAllister (10)
Carnell Williams (10)
Steven Jackson (10)
Jamal Lewis (8)
Chester Taylor (8)
Frank Gore (8)
Ahman Green (5)
Shaun Alexander (4)

[Fishercat]

Wah wah wah.

There's no rules about voting for the best, if there were, then these games would have no purpose. Everyone could tell you Pujols or Hafner were the best 1B choices...but that's no fun.

[Dam8610]

Can we put Addai in for Rhodes? I can't bring myself to feel positive about Rhodes.

[Lynch]

Not whining, just saying. Hell, I'm not even a fan. But I -do- acknowledge his talent and he's a top tier RB without question.


+ Alexander
- Green

LaDainian Tomlinson (13)
Tiki Barber (11)
Julius Jones (11)
Rudi Johnson (11)
Edgerrin James (10)
Willis McGahee (10)
Ronnie Brown (10)
Corey Dillon (10)
Lee Suggs (10)
Reuben Droughns (10)
Willie Parker (10)
Domanick Davis (10)
Dominic Rhodes (10)
Fred Taylor (10)
Chris Brown (10)
Mike Bell (10)
Larry Johnson (10)
Lamont Jordan (10)
Brian Westbrook (10)
Clinton Portis (10)
Cedric Benson (10)
Kevin Jones (10)
Warrick Dunn (10)
DeShaun Foster (10)
Deuce McAllister (10)
Carnell Williams (10)
Steven Jackson (10)
Jamal Lewis (8)
Chester Taylor (8)
Frank Gore (8)
Shaun Alexander (5)
Ahman Green (3)

[Rufio181]

Wah wah wah.

There's no rules about voting for the best, if there were, then these games would have no purpose. Everyone could tell you Pujols or Hafner were the best 1B choices...but that's no fun.

Wait what about Howard? And since you mentioned Hafner as a 1B, you got to include Big Papi.