Yankees vs Reds I mean...Reds, a legitimate baseball team

[BronxBomberz]

I'd take Dice K over any of that Yankees Garbage in the rotation, that includes Mussina and Joba.

How about Wang? Pettitte?

[Bon Bon]

How about Wang? Pettitte?

No doubt

[Mr. D™]

Reds* not Dreds

[Bon Bon]

The Reds are making the Yanks look like Skanks.

[BronxBomberz]

The Reds are making the Yanks look like Skanks.

Cardinals made Sox look like Dread Sox

[bwitty24]

Bon Bon, that is an awfully bold move taking Dice K over the 39 year old Mike Mussina. The thing about Dice K is that he walks too many people and is way overhyped.

[BronxBomberz]

Mussina has won at least 10 games every year since 1991, an MLB record. That's 17 seasons.

[ljshorty89]

Dice K has more talent at this point in their careers, but Mussina is more proven. Moose has been impressive. At this point, Dice K is one of the better pitchers in the league, despite his control issues. The guy hadn't lost a game before today. If you wouldn't take that from ANY pitcher in your rotation, you're nuts.

[bwitty24]

Wins and losses mean nothing for a pitcher. A pitcher can be very good and not have a good record, see Matt Cain and Scott Kazmir over the years. Just because the Sox put up a ton of runs a game doesn't make Dice K good. Giese pitched beautifully today and did not get the win. Joba pitched very well the other day and did not get the win. Wins and losses is a bad measurement.

[nyjunc]

BonBon: If you are going to talk trash do it somehwere else, we don't need your red sox garbage polluting the thread.


As for the game, Giese was great. He killed himself w/ that throwing error which led to the big inning but if you can't score it's hard to win. We had so many chances and couldn't break through, I hope we salvage the final game today.

[Mr. D™]

The Reds are making the Yanks look like Skanks.

Cardinals made Sox look like Dread Sox

[BronxBomberz]

Game start!

Quick 1st inning for Pettitte. Let's see if the offense breaks it's slump.

[GiantsFanatic]

BonBon: If you are going to talk trash do it somehwere else, we don't need your red sox garbage polluting the thread.


As for the game, Giese was great. He killed himself w/ that throwing error which led to the big inning but if you can't score it's hard to win. We had so many chances and couldn't break through, I hope we salvage the final game today.

You such a blind homer, your own fan started talking trash to Bon Bon about Dice K.

First of all Dice K sucks. Second of all, despite the loss the Yankees have to be happy about this game. Dan Giese pitched tremendously. You can't expect the offense to score every single game. The Yankees don't need offense, they need pitching and this is exactly what Giese provides.

[bwitty24]

I was responding to a statement I did not agree with.

[bwitty24]

Yankees Win!!! Big win today preventing the sweep.