Pitchers
Dontrelle Willis
Josh Johnson
Scott Olsen
Anibal Sanchez
Joe Borowski
Logan Kensing
Randy Messenger
Chris Resop
Taylor Tankersley
Jason Vargas
Batters
Miguel Olivo
Miguel Cabrera
Mike Jacobs
Hanley Ramirez
Dan Uggla
Joe Borchard
Reggie Abercrombie
Cody Ross
Josh Willingham
Jeremy Hermida
ELIMINATED
1. Matt Herges (2 votes)
2. Wes Helms (2 votes)
3. Alfredo Amezaga, Ricky Nolasco, Matt Treanor (all with 1 vote)