2012 Hall of Fame Ballot

[catman]

Here is the ballot that the writers can pick from: 2012 Official/Potential Hall of Fame Ballot - Baseball-Reference.com
Who gets in and who doesn't?

[Kingdom]

I'd vote for Larkin, McGwire, and Bagpipes.

[Slyder]

For Me it would be:
1 Larkin
2 Morris
3 Martinez

I'm not ready to forgive the steroids boys.

[Providence A's]

I'd like to see Larkin, Smith, McGriff. and Raines.

[Qdiddy]

1. Larkin
2. Smith
3. Raines
4. Williams

[love_that_reefer]

Larkin and Bagwell only.

[zodious]

Larkin and Bagwell only.

Larkin and the arm protector that bagwell wore because of how often he was beaned

[Porter]

if bagwell goes then edgar martinez should go.

[love_that_reefer]

Why is that?

[Porter]

very similar avg, obp and slg (bags at .948 and edgar at .933 for ops)

[love_that_reefer]

Bagwell has 140 more HRs and that tiny 2600 game edge of actually playing the field. I like Edgar and thought he was an exceptional hitter but I hold DH's to a higher standard. Bagwell belongs in the HOF before Edgar does but I guess I wouldn't cry if Edgar got in.

[Porter]

he did all that with one good eye (edgar)

[Kingdom]

Apparently people blindly assume Bagwell used steroids despite no proof. That makes those people as lame as the real voters who do the same. Larkin played in the same era of baseball too. But, people are blind. And lame. And just dumb.

[Kingdom]

And poop heads.

[Kingdom]

he did all that with one good eye (edgar)

Oooh, Edgar could make the X-Men Hall of Fame as the real life Cyclops!