Give us your All-Star roster

[Kingdom]

No, I was just saying I only saw McCann on your roster and I thought you meant Soto was someone who almost made it but didn't. Since they have the re-entry rule, 2 catchers are fine I think.

[HollywoodLeo]

Mofo only named the reserves.

[Kingdom]

Oh shit, he did, didn't he. Whoops.

[Porter]

Assuming all the starters are the same. Here would be my reserves

American (9 starters)
CA: Victor Martinez (BOS), Mike Napoli (LAA)
1B: Cabrera (DET), Youkilis (BOS)
2B: Kinsler (TEX), Wigginton (BAL, Re-entry candidate only BAL rep)
SS: Alex Gonzalez (TOR), Elvis Andrus (TEX)
3B: Adrian Beltre (BOS), Michael Young (TEX)
OF: David Dejesus (KC, only rep), Alex Rios (CWS), Torii Hunter (LAA), Nick Swisher (NYY)
DH: Paul Konerko (CWS)

SPs: Cliff Lee (SEA), David Price (TB), Clay Buchholz (BOS)**, John Lester (BOS), Jered Weaver (LAA), Felix Hernandez (SEA), Fausto Carmona (CLE's only rep)
RPs: Jose Valderde (DET), Mariano Rivera (NYY)***, Andrew Bailey (OAK's only rep), Rafael Soriano (TB)

**on DL would be replaced by Andy Pettitte
***said he would take ASG off, would be replaced by Neftali Feliz (TEX)

Ill do the damn NL tomorrow. I believe that is 35.

[Slyder]

I'm just ignoring the whole fan vote, just doing the full roster. If theres any overlooks Ill gladly Drop Soto for whoever, next to go would probably be Dunn.

National League:

Catcher:
Brian McCann Atl
Miguel Olivo Col to the Chagrin of Porter :P
Giovanni Soto CHC

First Base:
Adrian Gonzalez SD
Albert Pujols St. L.
Joey Votto Cin As mentioned before he is having the best season of all the NL 1b.
Adam Dunn Was One reason and one reason only... Home Run Derby Dunn vs Hamilton on who could hit the most prolific shots.

Second Base:
Brandon Phillips Cin
Martin Prado Atl
#Chase Utley Phi

Third Base:
Scott Rolen Cin
David Wright NYM
Ryan Zimmerman Was

Shortstop:
*Rafael Furcal LA
Hanley Ramirez Fla
#Troy Tulowitzki Col

Outfield:
Marlon Byrd CHC
Andre Either LA
Corey Hart Mil
Matt Kemp LA
Andrew McCutcheon Pit
*Colby Rasmus StL
Josh Willingham Was
Chris Young Ari

Starters:
Roy Halladay Phi
Tim Hudson Atl
Ubaldo Jimenez Col
Josh Johnson Fla
Mat Latos SD
Tim Lincecum SF
Roy Oswalt Hou
Adam Wainright StL

Relievers:
Heath Bell SD
Jonathan Broxton LA
Francisco Rodriguez NYM
Billy Wagner Atl
Brian Wilson SF

Feel free to let me know if theres any glaring omision.

My Lineup:
Martin Prado 2b
Hanley Ramirez SS
Joey Votto 1b/dh
Albert Pujols 1b/dh
Matt Kemp CF
Corey Hart LF
Andre Either RF
Miguel Olivo Ca
David Wright 3b