Hall of Fame %'s

[DirtyKash]

Please give Hall of Fame probabilities (from 0% to 100%) for the following players.

Vladimir Guerrero:
Alfonso Soriano:
Albert Pujols:
Miguel Tejada:
Ichiro:
Manny Ramirez:
David Ortiz:
Lance Berkman:
Michael Young:
Nomar Garciaparra:
Derek Jeter:
Jim Thome:
Andruw Jones:
Troy Glaus:
Carlos Delgado:
Alex Rodriguez:
Andy Pettitte:
Roy Halladay:
Johan Santana:
Mike Mussina:
John Smoltz:
Jason Schmidt:
Barry Zito:
Curt Schilling:
Billy Wagner:

[Kingdom]

Vladimir Guerrero: 100%
Alfonso Soriano: 0
Albert Pujols: 100
Miguel Tejada: 40
Ichiro: 20
Manny Ramirez: 99
David Ortiz: 10
Lance Berkman: 0 unless he hits 500 HR
Michael Young: 0
Nomar Garciaparra: 0
Derek Jeter: 100
Jim Thome: 0 if he doesn't hit 500 HR
Andruw Jones: 100
Troy Glaus: 0
Carlos Delgado: 0
Alex Rodriguez: 90 ish
Andy Pettitte: 0
Roy Halladay: 0
Johan Santana: 50
Mike Mussina: 25
John Smoltz: 99
Jason Schmidt: 0
Barry Zito: 1
Curt Schilling: 50
Billy Wagner: 10

Only injuries will stop ARod, Vlad, Pujols, etc.

[nyjunc]

Vladimir Guerrero: 90%
Alfonso Soriano: 50%(he's on his way but his career is still very young)
Albert Pujols: 95%(100% if he stays healthy)
Miguel Tejada: 60%
Ichiro: 40%
Manny Ramirez: 95%
David Ortiz: 40%(he's been great the last few years but he needs another 4-5 years at a top level)
Lance Berkman: 40%
Michael Young: 30%(too soon)
Nomar Garciaparra: 20%(was on his way but not anymore)
Derek Jeter: 100%
Jim Thome: 40%
Andruw Jones: 80%
Troy Glaus: 40%
Carlos Delgado: 20%
Alex Rodriguez: 100%
Andy Pettitte: 50%
Roy Halladay: 50%(if he could stay healthy he'd be much higher)
Johan Santana: 75%(still very young, needs to stay healthy)
Mike Mussina: 50%(I think he falls short unless he hangs on for a while for #300)
John Smoltz: 90%
Jason Schmidt: 30%
Barry Zito: 30%
Curt Schilling: 90%
Billy Wagner: 40%

[love_that_reefer]

As of right now?

Vladimir Guerrero: 50%
Alfonso Soriano: 40%
Albert Pujols: 60%
Miguel Tejada: 25%
Ichiro: 10%
Manny Ramirez: 96%
David Ortiz: 35%
Lance Berkman: 45%
Michael Young: 0%
Nomar Garciaparra: 3%
Derek Jeter: 87.6 %
Jim Thome: 40%
Andruw Jones: 50%
Troy Glaus: 30%
Carlos Delgado: 50%
Alex Rodriguez: 85%
Andy Pettitte: 55%
Roy Halladay: 50%
Johan Santana: 50%
Mike Mussina: 50%
John Smoltz: 70%
Jason Schmidt: 30%
Barry Zito: 50%
Curt Schilling: 50%
Billy Wagner: 65%

[nyjunc]

I just want to go over player by player and say who I think will get in:

Vladimir Guerrero: YES
Alfonso Soriano: Too soon to tell
Albert Pujols:a little early to say
Miguel Tejada: NO
Ichiro: NO
Manny Ramirez: YES
David Ortiz: NO
Lance Berkman: NO
Michael Young: NO
Nomar Garciaparra: NO
Derek Jeter: YES
Jim Thome: NO
Andruw Jones: YES
Troy Glaus: NO
Carlos Delgado: NO
Alex Rodriguez: YES
Andy Pettitte: NO
Roy Halladay: NO
Johan Santana: NO
Mike Mussina: NO
John Smoltz: YES
Jason Schmidt: NO
Barry Zito: NO
Curt Schilling: YES
Billy Wagner: NO

[Kingdom]

At this point I would also say no to Santana. But if he avoids major injury and keeps going at his current pace, his career numbers will be very good in the strikeouts, ERA, WHIP, and winning % areas. So I think if then, he's HoF material. Injuries killed Nomar's chances, otherwise he'd have a good shot at 3,000 hits with a nice batting average.

[Lance324]

Vladimir Guerrero: 75% His aggressive style could very well lead to injury
Alfonso Soriano: 50% Still too early to tell
Albert Pujols: 90% He's a lock if he continues to play like he has
Miguel Tejada: 25% Good Player, Not HOF
Ichiro: 15% Started in MLB too late in his career
Manny Ramirez: 95% He's probably borderline if he retired today
David Ortiz: 25% One Dimensional Player, when Manny leaves, he's in trouble
Lance Berkman: 10% Not even close
Michael Young: 0% Even further away
Nomar Garciaparra: 10% Way too injury prone, already lost part of his prime
Derek Jeter: 100% I don't consider him HOF, but he'll make it for sure
Jim Thome: 50% He may get to 500 HR
Andruw Jones: 80% His defense will boost his chances
Troy Glaus: 20% Not good enough
Carlos Delgado: 30% Good not Great
Alex Rodriguez: 99% He's a long barring major injury
Andy Pettitte: 10% Great Postseason Pitcher, nothing more
Roy Halladay: 40% He's a long way off yet
Johan Santana: 50% Verdict is still out on him
Mike Mussina: 50% Good pitcher, Again not HOF though
John Smoltz: 50% See above
Jason Schmidt: 0% He's not even close
Barry Zito: 10% Extremely overrated IMO
Curt Schilling: 80% He'll get in just cause of the hype, but probably shouldn't
Billy Wagner: 0% No Way

[GiantsFanatic]

Vladimir Guerrero: 100
Alfonso Soriano: 100
Albert Pujols: 100
Miguel Tejada: 70
Ichiro: 100
Manny Ramirez: 100
David Ortiz: 100
Lance Berkman: 30
Michael Young: 40
Nomar Garciaparra: 100
Derek Jeter: 0
Jim Thome: 100
Andruw Jones: 90
Troy Glaus: 27
Carlos Delgado: 100
Alex Rodriguez: 100
Andy Pettitte: 50
Roy Halladay: 100
Johan Santana: 100
Mike Mussina: 100
John Smoltz: 100
Jason Schmidt: 100
Barry Zito: 40
Curt Schilling: 100
Billy Wagner: 100

[nyjunc]