I've randomized the order by drawing cards out of a deck and the order is as follows:
1. Halladay_is_God - ALBERT PUJOLS
2. TypeZero - DAVID ORTIZ
3. HollywoodLeo - RYAN HOWARD
4. OrioleMagic - JAKE PEAVY
5. DirtyKash - JOSE REYES
6. General - BEN SHEETS
7. Kingdom_of_Zido - JOHAN SANTANA
8. Porter99 - DAVID WRIGHT
9. browntown653 - ALEX RODRIGUEZ
10. Dry1313 - VLADIMIR GUERRERO
11. Witlon - ALFONSO SORIANO
12. mntwinsfan