Who would you pick for Heisman?

[Kingdom]

There was once a time I made a poll for a preseason Heisman pick, and I put JaCory Harris on there. And I voted for him. I've hated myself since.


Alright, pick a winner on the count of..

[Hammer]

richardson, luck, barkley, rg3 in that order. those should be the 4 names invited to the presentation, with trent winning.

[Hammer]

change my pick based on the finalists... honey badger 4 heisman

[cjkalt]

Yea I'd vote for honey badger... he stepped up and was the man who turned the tide in the Oregon, Arkansas, UGA games... no other player stepped up like he did in the big Tier A games

[HollywoodLeo]

I'd say RGIII

[Qdiddy]

RG3, he put Baylor on the map, he's a class act and did it with much lessor talent around him. They all deserve it but I would go with him.

[Slyder]

For me it would have broken down like this:
Best Overall Player: Luck

Most Exciting Player: RG3

There's an element to the Heisman about personal character that keeps me from voting for Honey Badger although he did change many games for LSU this year.

I think Luck makes Stanford that much better and it will show when he is gone I would not be shocked to see Stanford fall back to 500 without him. He is by far the most polished QB prospect to be in a draft since Peyton Manning. He may get to learn with Peyton for a couple seasons I would be SHOCKED if Indy does not take him #1. Everywhere GM Bill Polian has been he's gone after a "franchise" qb and Peyton can't play forever.

Buffalo he signed Jim Kelly from the USFL.
Carolina he drafted Kerry Collins from Penn State.
Indy he drafted Peyton Manning inspite of ESPN's best shots to try and convince people the "freak" Ryan Leaf was better.

[HollywoodLeo]

I wish the Colts would have listened to ESPN.

[realmofotalk]

It sure would be nice for a change to see the Heisman go to the player that you would take if you had the #1 overall pick in the draft and assuming they're all eligible instead of this nonsense.