Reds Survivor, Crown a Winner

[Kingdom]

Vote for the winner. You're picking the better of the two, not who you want to get rid of.



Aaron Harang
Edwin Encarnacion


Voted off:
1. Quentin McCracken
2. Dave Williams
3. Jason LaRue
4. Joe Mays
5. Eric Milton
6. Brian Shackleford
7. Juan Castro
8. Royce Clayton
9. Javier Valentin
10. David Weathers
11. Brandon Claussen
12. Kyle Lohse
13. Gary Majewski
14. Rich Aurilia
15. Todd Coffey
16. Elizardo Ramirez
17. Rheal Cormier
18. Todd Hollandsworth
19. Chris Denorfia
20. Bill Bray
21. Eddie Guardado
22. Ken Griffey Jr.; David Ross
23. Scott Hatteberg (who knew!?!)
24. Brandon Phillips
25. Bronson Arroyo
26. Ryan Freel
27. Adam Dunn

[General]

Harang-atan.

[redsrbetter]

Harang for the win!

Two years in a row?

[CincyRedsFan30]

I vote for Edwin.

As good as Harang has been, 13 of his 27 starts have had him yielding either 4 or more Runs or less than 6 IP or both.

Edwin has a good OPS and has been especially good in the clutch.

[DirtyKash]

Encarnacion's VORP has me creaming myself. I vote for him.

[Reds_fan_4_life]

EdE Ftw! in your face Narron

[DravenX]

Edwin Encarnacion.

[redsfan28]

Harang has been better than EdE this season, plain and simple. I know its hard to compare a position player with a pitcher, especially since a pitcher is much more valuable to a team than a position player. Considering how pitching-starved this team has been the past few years, you HAVE to vote for Harang!

[MarinersFan87]

EdE.

[DirtyKash]

especially since a pitcher is much more valuable to a team than a position player.

if that's the case, why do people always seem to dismiss pitchers when it comes to MVP awards?

[General]

Because pitchers get the Cy.

[Dry1313]

Harang!

[Jesus Christ]

I vote for Edwin Encarnacion

[Kingdom]

Harang.

Quality pitching gets you more in life.

[NFLman2033]

Aaron Harang